Shopping Made Simple: Digital Recorders
Looking to record your favorite music and videos? Get ready to go digital
(continued)
Michael Riggs
October 2001
Once you’ve decided on a recording format, it’ll be time to choose a specific recorder. Here are some key features you should consider:
- Inputs and outputs. You can expect almost any digital audio recorder
to have at least stereo pairs of analog input and output jacks, and typically
there will also be inputs and outputs for direct digital connections. These
come in two flavors: coaxial (electrical) and Toslink optical (sometimes referred
to as “fiber optic”). One performs as well as the other. Just make sure the
connections on the recorder match those on the components you plan to hook
it up to.
- Recording-level indicators. When you’re recording from an analog
source, you’ll need to adjust the level of the input signal to prevent overload
on musical peaks. Look for peak-reading fluo res cent or LED level indicators
with rea son ably fine gradations (no more than a decibel or two per increment)
around the 0-dB red-line mark. If a deck doesn’t have level indicators, it
usually means there’s an automatic level control (ALC) in the circuit. That
makes things easy, but it also diminishes the recorded dynamic range. If you
want the best sound quality, ALCs are best avoided.
- Sampling-rate conversion. CD and MD both use a sampling rate of
44.1 kHz. However, some other digital formats (digital audio tape, or DAT,
for example) use different sampling rates. To make direct digital copies from
such sources, a CD or MD recorder must convert the input signal’s sampling
rate to 44.1 kHz. Many recorders now have circuits that perform such conversions
automatically. But you should check wheth er this seldom-used processing is
kept out of the circuit when the incoming signal’s sampling rate is already
44.1 kHz, to prevent any distortion the converter might introduce.
- CD synchro. This handy function starts recording automatically when
you hit play on the CD player you’re copying from.
- Dual trays. Many CD recorders now have dual disc trays to ease dubbing
from CD to CD-R and to serve as a basic two-disc CD changer. Some can record
from both trays. In most, however, one side is for playback only. Some MiniDisc
recorders also include a CD player (or even changer).
- High-speed dubbing. Dual-tray recorders normally allow you to copy
from one side to the other at faster than normal playback speed. Since the
dubbing is done digitally, there’s no penalty in sound quality. So all else
being equal, the faster a dual-tray CD or MD recorder can copy, the better.
- A/D and D/A converters. Digital recorders include analog-to-digital
(A/D) converters for making analog input signals into digital signals for
record ing and digital-to-analog (D/A) converters for reconstructing analog
output signals from recorded digital data. CD and MD are strictly 16-bit formats,
and although many players and recorders use 20- or 24-bit converters, CDs
and MDs can store only 16 bits of that range. Thus, while a 24-bit converter
might work exceptionally well over the 16-bit portion of its range that a
recorder or player actually puts to use, it won’t give you a 24-bit CD or
MD. Hard-disk recorders typically are designed for CD-level performance at
best, so the same caveat applies.