MUSIC REVIEW: The New Pornographers
Twin Cinema
Brett Milano
November 2005
|
Twin Cinema
Matador
Music •••½
Sound •••½
|
After two sets of fizzy hooks and classic pop homages (
three sets if you count leader
A.C. Newman’s solo album), you might expect the New Pornographers to get really ambitious and shoot for an epic. Instead, they’ve come up with . . . another collection of fizzy hooks and classic pop homages. Nothing necessarily wrong with that — and it’s hard to argue with songs as well crafted and infectiously upbeat as most of those on
Twin Cinema. There are danger signs, however. Newman’s more cute, show-tune side turns up a bit too often, and the trademark quotes get a little obvious. Yes, there’s more of
Neko Case this time around, and she pulls off a wicked Kim Deal impression on the already Pixies-ish “The Bones of an Idol.” But ultimately, the album spotlights the band’s softer, acoustic side. And that’s disappointing, because the songs that do push the envelope — either by getting tougher (the title track) or weirder (the Eastern-droning “The Bleeding Heart Show”) — are the ones that truly stand out.